My suggestion would be to go with the design that the alpine reps gave you, I've always believed in building enclosures to suggested manufacturer specs. They are the experts and they do extensive testing before making their recommendations. A lot of people think they know what they are talking about telling you to go with a larger box with more cu. ft but where are their credentials. I'm an industry person and have been fortunate enough to see some of the alpine testing methods and believe me they use all kinds of high tech stuff to come up with those test. Their testing goes way beyond simple leap test, so my point is that I would build it according to the manufacturer specs.