I think you are misinterpreting your wattage.Your amp is consuming 3,615.60 watts from the battery at 262 amps and 13.8 volts DC.
No amp is 100% efficient. Most amps are 70-85% efficient with the best being just over 90%. So lets say 80% efficiency. 80% of 3,615.60 is 2,892.48 watts that your amp is capable of putting out at the ohm load you tested. Some of that is lost to heat to the speaker so we take a root mean square measurement of a .707 loss.
So you multiply Max wattage by .707 to get RMS at
2,044.983 watts. This is what your subs are seeing
I have done extensive tests on the MTX 9500 to compare it to the T3 Audio TSS.
The TSS out performed the MTX, but the MTX 9500 d2 12 performed remarkably well. about 2000 rms daily is the max I would recommend and about 3,500 watts RMS for short 3 seconds burps for competition.
Thermaly these subs handle alot. They are very stiff and not too efficient so with 2) 12s and 2000 rms each I achieved 146.8 dB @ 46 hz on the termlab. The T3 TSS did 148.2 dB @46 hz on the termlab.
I dont think you can blow these subs with your amp's power and they should sound clean and play low.