Ahh, now we are in the "square vs circle" debate. A square woofer's problem, as cotjones is almost correct in saying, is stress related. When you ask a cone to move a large distance, 60 times a second, you put alot of stress on the cone. A square, being that all points on the edge aren't equidistant from it's center, creates natural weak points at each edge. This limits their linear excursion, once they move too far, the cone buckles, creating distortion. That isn't to say that square cones don't have advantes too though. A square cone has more surface area than a circle of the same radius. That means that per unit of excursion, you move more air with the square. So the linear excursion (xmax) of a square cone is inherently less, but it's vd (cone area) is inherently higher. Linear displacement, is vd*xmax, so both will have the same effect on the overall linear output of the system.