No, it was the student's fault. The student engaged in disruptive behavior.
If the recession was a real hardship on the family, one would assume that a friviolous cell phone would be the first thing to go. Yes, school polices adversely effect the financial situation of the families of poor students. Metro-Nashville schools has a policy that fines the parents of truant students. Truant students are disruptive to the classroom when they arrive late and because of compulsory education laws, they cannot tell the student to go to hell, like they would in a college classroom.