logic would dictate that something is wrong here. it just doesn't make sense that covering your entire ceiling by adding a complete bulk pack gives you 0.5db increase in spl but adding those 2 tiny pieces gives you a 0.1db increase. they cover what, maybe 1/8th of a sq ft at best? that says that either your are not testing it in the same manor each time or not testing it enough times each step of the way to get a true reading. i think you would be better off testing it 3-5 times after each application and using an average. too many variables to get an accurate reading from one time.
good luck on the install though. i did my entire trunk, trunk lid (3 layers), floor and front doors (inner and out skins). it's a pain in the *** to do but well worth it in the end.