Yes, it is definitely sig worthy, lol.... However, since you don't know much about sony xplode, it's not really fair to say it's only "marginally better". It is far superior to an xplode. I'm pretty sure he'll be getting much more out of the apsm than he did out of his old amp, even at 4 ohms,. I'm think he just has the gain a bit low, is all.This is so sig worthy it's not even funny.
While the AP is only marginally better than your old XPlode, was the Sony a 2 ohm or 4 ohm amp? I don't know much about them. If it is, you were probably getting more power @ 4 ohms with the Sony. Whereas the AP is onyl doing what... maybe 300-400w on a pair of 8 ohm subs?
I would suggest you double check the phase again though. Just because they are moving similarly, doesn't mean they are in phase. Just unhook one sub and see if it get louder.