I won't put him on it. I haven't been side by side w/a hooked up Type R. IF netherland ever brings them down from Denton, I'd actually have a chance to do some comparisons.
I'd a given my SE's more, but couldn't due to my amp. The coils never have gotten warm enough for the 'glue smell'.
When I was looking to originally purchase good subs, after purchasing the Polk GNX124's at CC, my requirement were 12", DVC, cast basket, full dustcap.
The three subs I liked at that time were:
Infinity Perfect 12.1d(vq)
Alpine Type-R
RE SE.
I liked the Infinity for it's variable Q, the type R had a good price point and I could pick it up at a store, and the RE had the right T/S for my application.
I related Xmax to potential SPL as I was limited w/Polk and so I ended up w/SEs.
Any of them would be fine. If you get them and don't like them, SELL THEM! You aren't marrying them!//content.invisioncic.com/y282845/emoticons/naughty.gif.94359f346c0f1259df8038d60b41863e.gif