Stay away from any ghey cars with special packages like - sport ridgeline or Vue redline.
I like the FJ, especially lifted.
Also WRX was an excellent suggestion. Vey fast and fun to drive...gets good mileage and is pretty discrete other than the hood scoop. My sister's got one and I love taking it out every chance I get.
3rd suggestion would have to be 350z, simply because I love mine. Probably the least convinient car ever made, I haven't driven any cars that were funner and the Dodge Viper GTS is the only faster one I've driven.