The benefit isn't just having more cone area (though that is a BIG benefit). The other benefit is that you've got multile motors and suspensions that you're spreading the power across and eliminating a lot of the power compression issues.
You're thinking in terms of the SPL lanes where you apply power for a vey short burst in most instances and at a single freq. With a daily dirven setup, you're looking at applying the power over long periods of time and across the full range of frequencies. The heat builds up quickly and the sub will actually get quieter the longer you continuously play it. If you're looking for 0.1s on the meter, a burp with a single sub is fine and it takes the cancellation issue that might cost you an inaudible amount of loss off the table. If you're looking for something that will pound over a long period of time, you want cone area and many motors.
I vote 16 8's for the "wow factor."