If she couldn't afford lipgloss, she can't afford 375 dollars. I'll tell you the truth, they can't get 375 dollars from you or her. I don't care if she signed a contract saying that she would pay them that for the next 10 years, she is underage, and therefore can not be held responsible for her actions without a conscenting adult present to witness and sign. They might as well have asked her to get them a unicorn or else she is going to get the electric chair. It really doesn't matter.
But still, lipgloss? What is this world coming to that people steal lipgloss (6 dollars)?
If she is underage she is going to be fine. I did a large spree of stealing from sears when I worked there in my youth and got caught stealing 3 camcorders. The total was over 3,000 dollars and it is considered a felony. BUT I was underage. So I got 3 months house arrest (taken down to 2) a 6 month probation and a 117 dollar fine.