**** lots of common sense observations:
1) If you know someone has a shady past why would you completely trust them.......fail
2) When someone breaks into a door with a screwdriver it messes up the door, wouldn't a reasonable person call the cops if they saw evidence of a break-in?............................fail
3) You have $2k to blow a night but no health insurance..............................................fail
4) You had $10k worth of stuff stolen but instead of going through the law and getting your money back you'd rather beat the crap out of someone and go to jail yourself?..........fail
5) I don't know either of you from Adam but common sense says you both got major problems
6) If you told him how people were stealing things (putting stuff by the curb) why would he do that if he knew you knew about it............................................................................fail