my budget pc, full of links, some one doubel check

all 4 of the maxtor drives ive owned failed in under a year... 60 gig lasted ~8 months, 200 gig lasted maybe 3, then it got RMAed and i got a brand new one, that one lasted around 6 months. Then I had some small 40 gig drive that died pretty fast as well.
Yea, I'm running on around 30% premature failure rate with Maxtor drives at home too. I'm REALLY nervous about buying another Maxtor (at least relying on it).

I haven't taken the plunge in several years, but I have to assume they're continuously working on improving the reliability, so I may give them another shot if they ever put out something with tasty size/performance.

 
... I should add that I have had drives from every manufacterer fail on me (except maybe Fujitsu and Seagate -- I can't remember a specific case where a Seagate failed).

The 2nd worse failure percentage was easily the IBM 60GXP series, followed by the 75GXP series, of which 90% of our corporate systems were running them at the time. We lost probably 20%-30% of those drives. But, that was a lot of years ago and Hitachi cleaned up IBM's mess after they bought their drive division off IBM.

The next worse failure percentage has been Western Digital. For the longest time, I feared them more than Maxtor, based on experience.

 
... I should add that I have had drives from every manufacterer fail on me (except maybe Fujitsu and Seagate -- I can't remember a specific case where a Seagate failed).
The 2nd worse failure percentage was easily the IBM 60GXP series, followed by the 75GXP series, of which 90% of our corporate systems were running them at the time. We lost probably 20%-30% of those drives. But, that was a lot of years ago and Hitachi cleaned up IBM's mess after they bought their drive division off IBM.

The next worse failure percentage has been Western Digital. For the longest time, I feared them more than Maxtor, based on experience.
Ive also had 2 of the IBM 60GXPs fail on me. They ran hot and were pretty noisy as well.

 
Unless you *really* need the extra desk space, an LCD isn't worth it. CRTs have better picture quality, are cheaper, and can actually render black right.

 
Activity
No one is currently typing a reply...

About this thread

vosschs

5,000+ posts
Banned
Thread starter
vosschs
Joined
Location
just east of STL
Start date
Participants
Who Replied
Replies
41
Views
287
Last reply date
Last reply from
vosschs
IMG_20260516_193114554_HDR.jpg

sherbanater

    May 16, 2026
  • 0
  • 0
IMG_20260516_192955471_HDR.jpg

sherbanater

    May 16, 2026
  • 0
  • 0

New threads

Top