Logo decision

[DubbDesigns 10+ year member]

I am trying to create a logo for my site, I have these two, I like the second one, however my friends like the first one and say it owns( I built it about 5 month's ago while learning photoshop //content.invisioncic.com/y282845/emoticons/crap.gif.7f4dd41e3e9b23fbd170a1ee6f65cecc.gif ). Which one do you all like?

Or my fav

Or should I go back to the drawing board?

Click to read more...

 

[Showrides]

I am trying to create a logo for my site, I have these two, I like the second one, however my friends like the first one and say it owns( I built it about 5 month's ago while learning photoshop //content.invisioncic.com/y282845/emoticons/crap.gif.7f4dd41e3e9b23fbd170a1ee6f65cecc.gif ). Which one do you all like?

Or my fav

Or should I go back to the drawing board?

I like the 2nd one a lot better. Much clearer and looks more professional. I wouldn't go any fancier than that.

 

[Raven 10+ year member]

I see where your friends are coming from. As logos go, simplicity is teh win. However, if you use real alpha channels then I think the second logo walks all over the first one. =) It gives a wow factor when you import it into different colored backgrounds.

Like mine? 3 years old, photoshop not involved.

 

[DubbDesigns 10+ year member]

Yea, I think the simplicity of the second one will fit into most of my stuff, easy to work with, as with the first one... I would have to do alot of work to get it to fit on a dark bg

 

[Raven 10+ year member]

Yea, I think the simplicity of the second one will fit into most of my stuff, easy to work with, as with the first one... I would have to do alot of work to get it to fit on a dark bg

Alpha channels FTW! Really, I did it that way expecting to find the background color I wanted, then export as JPG (This was 2003, mind you. 8bit alpha was not popular) and just never finished. =) It makes blending a breeze at the cost of file size.

 

[project f-150 10+ year member]

Go with number 2

 

[req 5,000+ posts]

meh. looks like you are still in highschool.

 

[DubbDesigns 10+ year member]

meh. looks like you are still in highschool.

That's because I am....

 

[ndnbolla 10+ year member]

Of the two, I like the 2nd one better. But I still think you can make that one a bit better.

It looks a little too tall for me. I would say either slim it up height-wise or widen it up.

But definetly better than the original logo.

 

[DubbDesigns 10+ year member]

Of the two, I like the 2nd one better. But I still think you can make that one a bit better.
It looks a little too tall for me. I would say either slim it up height-wise or widen it up.

But definetly better than the original logo.

I just made it big so you can see it better. It will be about half that size on the site.

 

[bigwheel15 10+ year member]

#2.

 

[DubbDesigns 10+ year member]

I decided on #2. This is what I have done so far for the new top for my site.

I post a link to it, because it is pretty wide, and do not want to make the forums wide.

http://dubbdesigns.com/top_2.jpg I still gotta do some work to it, but the logo fits in pretty well, I think.

 

[Kenny Pollock 10+ year member]

No offense intented but I think you should use a more original shape... I'm not sure where I saw it before, but I've seen that same shape on many sites.

 

[Jdizzle 10+ year member]

fix the pics i wanna see

 

[DubbDesigns 10+ year member]

No offense intented but I think you should use a more original shape... I'm not sure where I saw it before, but I've seen that same shape on many sites.

Probably have seen it other places, maybe that was my inspiration, I may have seen it before, just don't remember seeing it. Oh well. If I think of a new one I will use it, but for now I guess I will stick with this one.