DD makes great woofers, but you're talking about their next to lowest line model. It's rated for 500 RMS, if I'm not mistaken, and can probably take a good bit more if you're not stupid. The Type R is Alpines signature "loud" subwoofer. A 12" Type R is also rated at 500 RMS and will take 1,000 rms daily(as should the 1512). What are your price points? Either way you look at it, the PA3000DB at 1ohm is too much power for either single woofer.
I do not have experience with the 1500 series of DD, so I cannot speak for which one will "actually" be louder in a given box. I do think it would be a fairly close race. Are we taking bets? I'd put a few pennies on the Type R. **EDIT** - - Please note, this is just a stupid opinion and made for laughs and giggles. Do not use this previous statement as any determining factor in your decision. Thank you. **EDIT**