Which is Better Class A/B or Class D

yea, class c are basically useless in car audio. d's are mre efficient, but distort more especially at high frequencies. a class and b class have very little distortion but only about 50% efficient.

well, i basically reitterated what other people have already said. so that was a waste of time. but im going to post it anyway so i didnt write this for nothing

 
Class A- best fidelity. One transistor handles the entire waveform both positive and negative sides. The only limitation on its fidelity is the linearity of the transistors in the output stages of the amp. The transistors are always partially on so they have to get rid of a ton of heat and as a result are only about 25% efficient.

Class B- two transistors in a push-pull configuration recreate the wave form. One handles the positive side and one handles the negative side. If one is on the other is off, and there is usually audible distortion at the zero point as one switches off and the other on.

Class A/B- Two transistors in a push-pull configuration but with some overlap around the zero point. The positive transistor stays on slightly below the zero voltage line and the negative transistor switches on just above the zero-line. The result is better fidelity than a Class B and better efficiency than a Class A. This is the most common type car amp.

Class C- doesn't even create the whole waveform. Useless for accurate audio reproduction but very efficient. Typiclally used in megaphones and such where battery life is more important than fidelity.

Class D- approximates the wave form by pulsing the rail voltage. The amp is basically a switching power supply with the goal an approximation of the input signal rather than a steady voltage. The output is then sent through a low pass filter to filter out the switching frequency noise. The output devices are high speed devices that are either completely on or completely off. As such there is minimal heat generated by the output devices. In addition to being an approximation of the waveform, the frequency range of the amp is very limited. In order to maximize the efficiency, the switching frequency must be fairly low and a first order filter on the output will leave some artifacts of the switching noise at higher frequencies. Because efficiency is more important than absolute fidelity when it comes to subs, Class D amps are a good choice for subs. Mids and highs don't need as much power and efficiency isn't as important as fidelity so they are not generally made as full range amps, although it can be done.

Class T- uses a proprietary chip to create what is effectively a Class D amp with a variable switching frequency capable of full range operation. It is not a linear amp though it comes pretty close. It does sound different than a Class A or A/B, but most speakers cannot bring out the differences and most people wouldn't know what they are hearing different. They are more efficient than Class A and A/B and not as efficient as Class D. Best case the Class T amp is about 80% efficient.

IMHO Class T amps are not worth the sacrifice in fidelity for the boost in efficiency because typically the difference in current draw real world is on the order of only a few amps. With a sub amp the difference is typically much larger and unless absolute fidelity is your end goal, then a Class D amp is the way to go for subs. Typically you are looking at halving your power consumption on your highest drawing item when going with a Class D over a Class A/B for the same amount of power. For many people, that can easily be the difference between being able to use the stock alternator and having to upgrade.

 
Its all about efficiency for the most part- Class D typically play up to 200hz(mine does)

Some prefer a/b to produce better SQ, dunno how, maybe because they can play subs higher (there some subs that play 500hz or so, I haven't noticed a difference since I crossover my frontstage between 80hz to 125hz-

 
How amps are classed depends on how the output transisters handle the + and - halves of the signal.

Class A: The transisters are always on. Very clean, ultra low distortion but they run very hot and are inefficant as heck. Thats why there soooo well.... HOT!

Basicaly alot of power goes in for very little output.

Class B: Use different parts of the circut to deal with the + and - halves of the signal. The output transisters are always switching. They are more efficient and run cooler but have much higher distortion rates than class A.

Class A/B: are a combination of?? you guessed it A and B designs. The most widely used amps. Odds are if you own a amp its a class A/B. Good for any application. subs, mids and highs.

Class D: Use a design where the transistors are either on or off. Hence the marketing guys calling them "digital" They are not true digital but hey! They got away with it for awhile!

Class D amps are very efficient so they run cool but have high distortion rates kinda like class B's and have a limited frequency responce. 20Hz to 200 Hz is normal. They work great for subs cuz they produce alot of power with less current, are small for the amount of power they produce and are cheaper per watt. The high distortion means very little with subs because the human ear does not hear distortion untill much higher levels at low frequencies.

Class T: A new amp class that is really a class D but with a tripath chip included. I dont know how it works for sure but supposed to have the benifits of a D and the low distortion of a A/B. I would be wary of them untill they prove themselves a little more.

High current amps: are normally class A/B designs they have large banks of output transisters and huge power supplys. The are stable into very low ohm loads. A good example is the kickers XS 100. 50 watts x 2 at 4ohm stereo but over 1000 at 1ohm mono. The famous "cheater" type amps you might have heard about.

 
Activity
No one is currently typing a reply...
Old Thread: Please note, there have been no replies in this thread for over 3 years!
Content in this thread may no longer be relevant.
Perhaps it would be better to start a new thread instead.

About this thread

monte_carlo97

10+ year member
Power Acoustik Punk
Thread starter
monte_carlo97
Joined
Location
Central Ohio
Start date
Participants
Who Replied
Replies
39
Views
5,415
Last reply date
Last reply from
helotaxi
IMG_20260513_214311575.jpg

ThxOne

    May 13, 2026
  • 0
  • 0
IMG_20260513_213956814.jpg

ThxOne

    May 13, 2026
  • 0
  • 0

New threads

Top