Extra batts definetly help. Have you metered your voltage drops at the amp and made sure its doing ok? Im running about 1600w in my car all together with 2 batts and a stock 63 or 80 amp alt. My voltage drops at night, but i can wang pretty much full tilt all day and be fine, however running a real weak alt with more batteries isnt always a good idea, if you forget to let your car idle for a minute or 2 with everything off before shutting it down you could have trouble starting it if your batts are drained, unless youre running an isolator or something. However id go by the ol volts X amps theory to be safe.