I didn't see the thread. While I want to defend him, I think he shouldn't have used notebook paper as people consider that cheap. Whereas newsprint is okay....
I always take pictures of the packaging process and ask the buyer if he feels the packaging is sufficient.
If there are any qualms afterwards, I'll just post where the buyer felt it was sufficient. That should clear my name with the forum.
But I am never cheap on the packaging. That is why I quit selling those eDs. It was more expensive to ship than the money I got. I could have saved money by throwing it in the trash.