trumpet
5,000+ posts
Barry Schanz
First, don't compare the gain knob to a volume knob. It's not what you said but it's a common mistake. The gain setting is to match the amp to what your RCAs are sending from the head unit. If it sounds good with the gain lower and the head unit turned up then leave it that way. If it sounds worse with the gain higher you're likely driving the amp into clipping or it's got high distortion. Your head unit's equalizer settings might also be a factor. You want those all flat or zeroed out while setting the gain. Search YouTube or Google for how to set your amp's gain. You can do it with a $10 digital multimeter.