Which would sound better?

[whitedragon551 5,000+ posts]

id get this and wire it into 4 ohms
WoofersEtc.com - RWE-302 - MB Quart 12" 1000 Watt Reference Series Subwoofer

heres how to wire it JL Audio - Car Audio Systems

and yes, MBQ makes nice subs

The one you linked is nice because it was OEM'd by Rockford Fosgate. The new ones are most likely junk.

 

[Linkz 10+ year member]

See if you can find an rwe352 from MB Quart. They sound great in 1.5cuft sealed box. It's a 15", around $100 last I checked.

The one you linked is nice because it was OEM'd by Rockford Fosgate. The new ones are most likely junk.

I can back that up. When I took apart my sub after I smashed the coil, it had a RE motor in it.