I would stay away from any of the motorola phone's. They are complete crap compared to what they use to be. I couldn't get service on one in my house, the battery even properly trained would only last 4-5 hours without any usage in flight mode, the keyboard's liked to stop working, and they constantly rebooted without any warning. I upgraded to the HTC Touch Pro which was really nice phone as well. But much like you I didn't want the data plan so I've now switched to the Env Touch and it's been great. I can use the phone all night, play a game of madden on it, check facebook, myspace, all the sports scores, and text at work for most of the night and still have over half a battery left after 10 hours. The internet browser is really good too, the touch screen is really smooth and accurate, and the camera is pretty good for pictures and videos.
The only thing I don't like about it is the fact you can't leave the mobile IM or any of the other program's like that open when you keylock the phone. It make's you end them all before it will lock it out. Another thing I don't like is the shitty people are verizon taking 2 week's to ship me the phone and not putting me on the right plan then trying to bill me $489 because of all the text and picture messaging I do. But they ended up fixing it after a little *****ing at them and I end up paying $60 a month with the 5000 text plan as compared to the $112 I was having to pay for my HTC Touch with the data plan you're required to have.