It all depends on what you like....if you're an audiophile/SQ junkie, then I'd probably agree, but if you're an SPL freak, the W3 would be one of the worst choices.
In case you still havent made up your mind, I aggree with the above posts:
JL AUdio 12w3v2 for SQ, and Kicker COmp for SPL
MY OPINION: JL, becasue 2 - 12"s should still have the ability to hit, plus you already know the SQ is there. Also rememeber the right amp, enclosure, and install will make a BIG difference.