My honest advice is ditch the TV tuner idea. It will be impossible to keep a good signal while driving. While parked, you can get a good signal on a particular channel if you drive around and find the best spot and face exactly the right direction. You'll need a big enough open space (parking lot) to do this. Then, if you want to watch a different channel, be prepared to move again.
If you do get a tuner, make sure it comes with the antenna setup, or you'll just have to purchase that separately. And remember, they are essentially "rabbit ears" just like you'd have at home if you didn't have dish or cable.
I had the Alpine TUE-T151 for a while, and it sucked. I don't blame it on the tuner, it's just a futile idea in the first place. I now have an external DVD player in the back of my truck, which has a tuner built in, but I have never even tried it out.
To answer your question though, I don't have any experience with those tuners you listed. I doubt that any will work much better than the next. You might as well get a cheap one if at all.