In this case the second would probably be much better as a vented enclosure woofer. The motor strength is much higher, BL^2/Re of 114 vs 54.45 for woofer one. The higher motor strength means you can excite the resonance of the port much more, meaning more output in a vented box. Also, it is clear that woofer 2 also has more mass as the Fs is lower but Vas is still lower. More motor plus more mass is how you create output in a vented box.
Woofer 1 has a larger Sd, but with woofer 2 having more Xmax it displaces more air. More displacement, more motor strength, and more mass all equals much more output in a vented enclosure.
John