Bah. If those are your very only two choices I would go with the JL speakers. To tell you the truth, when I got my Infinities I was pretty disappointed with them. When they say that it is a sound quality speaker, it really is. There are no big power suprises. If you want some good power with good sound quality, get the JL Audio W6. However, if you can get other speakers, I also recommend Kicker speakers. I heard the Kicker Solo-Baric 12L7 and fell in love it it. It is so powerful and it rocks everything within a 50 foot radius. So, I decided that I would get 2 Kicker Solo-Baric 15L7s. Oh man.... My 2 cents: Go with JL Audio if you can only get one of those two, but if you want to broaden your options, get the Kicker Solo Baric L7. Good luck.