ive had 10s sealed and ported, 12s sealed, 15s sealed and ported. imo its more about the sub than the box assuming the box is built correctly.
my SQ 10s sounded better than anything because they are SQ. my rockford 12s sealed still get a little sloppy in a pre fab box. i had a dc lvl 3 15 and fi ssd 15 sealed and ported. they didnt get sloppy, but they dont sound as good as my SQ 10s. it was very noticeable too. but like i said they didnt sound bad or sloppy, just not as good, but they are built to be loud and sound good, not loud and sound excellent
u know ur square subs sound sloppy, so avoid them.