did you poke that steak with a screwdriver lol look at the holes u put in it. When cooking steak common misconception dont cut it or stab with a fork. Everyone thinks this is letting the juice in but in reality its letting the juices out of the middle. Just cook it the way it is if you want to marinate it let it marinate for 12-24 hrs. Then you have very good steak.
I made a unbelievable prime rib the other day so good couldnt have been any better. Ive been to all the best steak houses in Boston and mine was just as good if not better.