I have it for 360 and think it looks ok. I am plying it through component on a 720p tv and would say it looks good, but not spectacular. As for the gameplay I like the idea of the constantly adjusting difficulty, but feel its terribly flawed. My pass defense is All Madden, but in the game my pass defense is terrible. And even with quite a few 100+ qb rating games my pass offense is still near rookie level. Its like if you are not passing **** near 400 yards a game it thinks you ****.
And 2K games NFL series destroyed Madden. EA could not touch them gameplay wise.