Ive lived in a lot of different states over the years. Surprisingly (to me at least), the seeming sensibility of speed limits seems to vary quite a bit depending on the state you are in. Midwestern states seem to be more conservative, while western states seem to be less so. Southern states seem to be hit or miss. Either way, I think its a bit naive to suggest speed limits are only for revenue generation, or strictly based on safety. The truth lies somewhere in between.
You saying the OP was traveling on a road that could easily support 45mph is simply a guess on your part. Yes speed limits tend to be rated conservatively more than recklessly (obviously), if in either direction... but some speed limits are right on the money. And speed limits have to take all situations into account.. is it a bright sunny summer day with high visibility, a foggy fall evening when visibility is poor? Is it raining heavily? Snowing? All these situations have to be accounted for, and leaving that up to each individual driver would lead to abuse based on the notion everyone thinks they are an above average driver, or above the rules. And sometimes statistics point out problem areas that common sense does not detect. Who knows why some certain seemingly innocuous curve on a road claims a statistically high number of lives each year, but if it does, it is the govt's responsibility to address the problem.
In the end, I guess I'll be that do gooder you talked about and say obey the speed limit. If the speed limits in your area are unjustly low, we have a system in which you can voice your opinion. Plenty of ways to do so. If you chose not to, and simply break the law... fine. But dont come here and ***** you were treated unfairly when the cop didnt let you off with a warning. The way i see it, you dont just take your life in your hands when you speed, you take the lives of everyone around in your hands too. A responsibility many people take far too lightly these days. Do I speed sometimes? Sure, im not suggesting I dont. But Im not so naive as to suggest there is no good reason for speed limits other than to generate revenue, or suggest most all speed limits are too low. But then, Im not so important that my time is too valuable to not be worth allowing me to leave for my destination 1-5 minutes sooner so that I can get there on time without doing 9mph over the limit.
If you want to discuss revenue, lets look at the other side of the coin. Its well know cops let people go 5mph over the limit before even considering pulling them over (usually). In my highschool drivers ed class years ago, the officer who came in to talk to us even said this. What happens when the vast majority of people assume they have the right to break the law by 5mph? The cops then have the right to pull over virtually anyone, at any time. Bam, automatic insurance policy to generate revenue, and to invade our privacy virtually at will. But as said above, if you want to fight this, dont use that 5mph that they 'give' you. 9mph? You should assume you'll get pulled over for that if a cop sees you. And assuming you will get a warning is just being naive. Complaining about it here only shows a lack of experience in dealing with this situation.
I'm simply responding to the OP who posted the thread with my opinion. I would not be
bitching on this forum about getting a speeding ticket, trust me!
You are correct in that I was over generalizing a bit as I am sure that certain states are more liberal than others. For example, in my state most cops aren't going to pull you over unless you are doing at least 10-15 mph over the limit, and even then, well, they aren't as uptight about it as they are in other states. Also, if you are in my state with an out of state license plate, you are more likely to get pulled over as they figure you will just pay the fine versus fighting it. My state also does not directly impact your insurance rates with a speeding ticket. A state like MA, well, totally different story.
I don't "speed" to break the law just to tweak the local constabulary. I drive at a speed I am conmfortable with which means I am not screaming down the road nor am I putting along 5 to 10 mph BELOW the limit. Trust me, in my area, people cruising along BELOW the speed limit is pretty common. And yes, it drives me nuts. If they could at LEAST go the speed limit it would be nice. And for those who love to use the passing lane on freeways/highways as their personal cruising lane at the speed limit or 5 MPH over drives me nuts as well. It's a PASSING lane, not a CRUISING lane. And when you do attempt to pull into the passing lane, LOOK in your rearview or side mirror first AND if you see someone coming up in the passing lane, take a few seconds to see how fast they are closing the distance. Again, it drives me nuts when I am passing a group of cars and someone in the group decides they are going to pass and pops right out in front of me that requires me to slam on the brakes. There are a lot of people out there who drive with no regard for everyone else around them. I am a very alert, constantly vigilant AND concientious driver. I'm always scanning and watching out for the bozo who is not paying attention. Yes, I do let people go when I could easily cut them off like most people do. Yes, I do actually know what a yield sign means. And when someone does cut me off, I simply smile and wave.
When I get in my truck, I am intent on getting from point A to point B, period. I'm not out there to simply cruise along and go so
damn slow I can watch a pair of squirrels mating along the side of the road. And yes, in my state, most of the speed limits are set ridiculously low, they just are.
And most cops do give me a warning when/if they do pull me over, radar detector or not. Why? Because I am polite and I haven't had a speeding ticket since 1989 (aka, no history). Being polite, not admitting how fast you were going and having a clean history goes a long way to not getting the actual ticket.