Jug vs eD A vs RE XXX

[l0ckjaw 10+ year member]

which is gonna out-pound which? for argument's sake, say they're all 15's. oh, running like 1200watts on a good amp, and in a decent ported box.

Click to read more...

 

[badi 10+ year member]

I havent heard any of them, but I'll guess for SPL:

1. Jug

2. ed.A

3. XXX

I think a lot depends on the enclosure as well

 

[thinkbig 10+ year member]

You need to consider the cone area and the efficiency of the sub as well. One advantage to the 15a is you have a flat cone/piston so you have a little bit more cone area. The Jug is a very beefy sub that was made strictly for SPL and the XXX is a little more oriented toward SPL as well. I've seen them all perform well in the SPL arena. If each are in their ideal enclosure, I think you are going to have very similar results in output. It's a tough decision being they are all excellent drivers, so you really can't go wrong with any of them.

 

[Qckrun 10+ year member]

You need to consider the cone area and the efficiency of the sub as well. One advantage to the 15a is you have a flat cone/piston so you have a little bit more cone area. The Jug is a very beefy sub that was made strictly for SPL and the XXX is a little more oriented toward SPL as well. I've seen them all perform well in the SPL arena. If each are in their ideal enclosure, I think you are going to have very similar results in output. It's a tough decision being they are all excellent drivers, so you really can't go wrong with any of them.

1. Juggy

2. XXX (Juggy and XXX can be switched around)

3. Brahma

4. Ed A

I know you didnt have the Brahma in there but it can get louder than an A.

 

[SPLThunder 10+ year member]

You need to consider the cone area and the efficiency of the sub as well. One advantage to the 15a is you have a flat cone/piston so you have a little bit more cone area. The Jug is a very beefy sub that was made strictly for SPL and the XXX is a little more oriented toward SPL as well. I've seen them all perform well in the SPL arena. If each are in their ideal enclosure, I think you are going to have very similar results in output. It's a tough decision being they are all excellent drivers, so you really can't go wrong with any of them.

How do you get more cone area out of a flat cone? If the A does have more area it isnt because of a flat cone. It would be a larger diameter. enough to make up for the conic shape of a traditional cone.

 

[anaranchi 10+ year member]

wtf is a Juggy or jug . never heard of it before. please post pics if u have any. or direct me to a site that does

and look into the DPs

 

[Randy Savage 5,000+ posts]

http://www.mmatsproaudio.com

http://www.incriminatoraudio.com

With 1200 to each, they should all be pretty close to each other...

Start throwing some serious power at them...the A will be left behind...

 

[l0ckjaw 10+ year member]

If anyone knows of any other subs that top those in the thump department, by all means speak up. I just knew those to be, at the very least, up there in the ranks. Like, what about those SI Magnum D2's, I heard those thump with the best of 'em.

 

[marleyskater420 5,000+ posts]

If anyone knows of any other subs that top those in the thump department, by all means speak up. I just knew those to be, at the very least, up there in the ranks. Like, what about those SI Magnum D2's, I heard those thump with the best of 'em.

yup!in fact im getting a d2(well jon is)so heeheh i get to play with one!oh dd9915..csx 15...the

1.juggy

2.xxx or brahma...depends on install

3.A

you can go w/ shocker..solox..cmpx2..imdax(eh)stroker..uhmm i dont have my history book so i cant say(i wrote all the subs on the back...i get bored...what can i say... //content.invisioncic.com/y282845/emoticons/biggrin.gif.d71a5d36fcbab170f2364c9f2e3946cb.gif )

 

[eddie23452 10+ year member]

What about the magnum d2 doesnt that sb hit hard....would that be good choice

 

[loserpunk 10+ year member]

if spl is all thats desired a 9515 should be well suited....what about the H2's and the HCCA

 

[k-mart 10+ year member]

What about the magnum d2 doesnt that sb hit hard....would that be good choice

Very good subs.....tho it doesn't come in a 15.........still would be a great choice though.

 

[l0ckjaw 10+ year member]

What about the XXX 18"? I mean, granted it's got a few inches extra, but still. And for any clarification, I gotta have the hardest hitting sub [without costing $5000 and such], if I have to throw 2000watts at it, whatever, and I don't want it to be 100% distortion. The biggest box would be about 6-7 cu.ft. ported. You guys tell me, you're the experts.

 

[marleyskater420 5,000+ posts]

What about the XXX 18"? I mean, granted it's got a few inches extra, but still. And for any clarification, I gotta have the hardest hitting sub [without costing $5000 and such], if I have to throw 2000watts at it, whatever, and I don't want it to be 100% distortion. The biggest box would be about 6-7 cu.ft. ported. You guys tell me, you're the experts.

haha the exactly the system i just designed for me friend.18"XXX auduobahn hct1500(eh...) 7^3..34hz or so

 

[havoc06 10+ year member]

The H2s are definately tight...and are pretty musical too. THe juggs im sellin were loud as hell, but the sq on them wasnt all that...IF its pure spl you want though, start focusing on more power than 1200 watts..that will help more than the sub your going with