Is Tom Brady the best QB the NFL will ever see?

[konechiwa 10+ year member]

Does it not enter your pea brain that perhaps those players put up numbers because of Brady? Those numbers aren't even great numbers to begin with. They didn't even have a thousand yard rusher. Wes Welker's career best was 67 catches and 600+ yards. He plays with Brady and has 110+ catches and over a thousand yards. Randy Moss has a career year with Brady. Brady made his receivers better.

THey didn't have an 1000 rusher because they use backups effictively and had injuries. Plus they went really pass-happy dumbass.

Does that mean Joe Montana made Jerry Rice good? Jerry Rice must **** because Joe Montana was such a good QB. He is obviously overrated. Brady is good because nobody touched him in the regular season. It wasn't up to him to protect himself. The offensive line did that. So lets credit the offensive line.

 

[konechiwa 10+ year member]

on another note, who was welkers QB? did they have any one even close to Brady? No.

 

[GenderBender]

on another note, who was welkers QB? did they have any one even close to Brady? No.

So you are validating my point then? Randy Moss was a great receiver without Brady, but had a career year with Brady. Givens, Branch, Caldwell etc. are not great players. You can go to any super bowl winning team and they will have a great offensive line. That is where championships are won.

 

[konechiwa 10+ year member]

So you are validating my point then? Randy Moss was a great receiver without Brady, but had a career year with Brady. Givens, Branch, Caldwell etc. are not great players. You can go to any super bowl winning team and they will have a great offensive line. That is where championships are won.

no i'm using your reasoning to say welker is a great WR that finally had a great QB to connect with.

If it's obviously the QB, then welker could do nothing and that is the reason why his previous career highs were lower.

Regardless, if you think the patriots have no good offensive players besides moss, then you are an idiot.

Thats plain and simple.

 

[dynamcpunk 10+ year member]

If your trying to say that Brady isn't in the top 10 best of all time then your the idiot. I don't understand why everyone always wants to argue and say that Brady is only good because of the players around him, but no one ever argue's that Manning is only good becuase of the players around him.

 

[konechiwa 10+ year member]

If your trying to say that Brady isn't in the top 10 best of all time then your the idiot. I don't understand why everyone always wants to argue and say that Brady is only good because of the players around him, but no one ever argue's that Manning is only good becuase of the players around him.

did i ever say that? NO

was i talking about that? NO

so lets be good and be quite. Besides the fact that Peyton Manning is a more talented QB (not more skilled).

I never said Brady wasn't top 10. In fact no one was. If you read the title, it says "Is Tom Brady the best QB the NFL will ever see?" Brady is definitely one of the best QB's ever. His playoff record and previous statistics alone could prove that. I'm simply saying that it's a little far-fetched to judge someone solely on a career year.

 

[multimaster 10+ year member]

Brett Favre will be a legend.

 

[95ZJ 10+ year member]

Troy Aikman is alright, but the best ever has to be Sammy Baugh //content.invisioncic.com/y282845/emoticons/fyi.gif.9f1f679348da7204ce960cfc74bca8e0.gif.

 

[soloXgt 10+ year member]

Trent Edwards huh?? reasons please.

 

[ace_800 5,000+ posts]

Best pure pocket passer ever was Marino...