http://forum.soundillusions.net/article.php?a=214
GSteg asks "Is there really a SQ difference between amps that puts out about the same amount of power?"
My take: yes. A Watt is a Watt' date=' sure. It's a defined amount. But not all amps with the same power will sound the same. You can have frequency response differences, THD/IMD, S/N, dynamics linearity and other differences between amps.
Many have taken the whole "a Watt is a Watt" fact to mean that all amps will sound the same. To those I say take a listen to a 20W Fender bass guitar cab amp with an old tube and a 20W Pass Labs class A unit. Just the bandwidth differences alone will make it easy to distinguish!
Can you hear a difference between a 90 minute cassette and an 80 minute CD? Wow and flutter, rumble, S/N, bandwidth are all different, even if the amount of music covered on each medium is the same.
This also gets into the whole "audio jewelry/tweak" region of things. You know, cryo treated cables, wood disks in the listening room, green ink on the edges of your CD, etc. Many who (wrongly) espouse that all amps of the same power sound about the same also poo-poo these tweaks. But in fact I believe they are wrong.
You see, there's more to hearing than just the physics of the sound. We don't just hear, we perceive. And this means the physical act of reception of an acoustical wave (hearing) and interpreting the received waveform (perception). Perception - by definition - includes our mental state - our "take" - on the sound. Anyone who's worked in audio development for products for multiple cultures will quickly learn what one culture considers as bass heavy, another will think of as bass shy. Same sonic/acoustic event, but perceptually different.
I think this needs to be considered when discussing audio tweaks and sound quality. Often times a person will "prefer" a cable over another. Not because of any audible difference (ABX testing bears this out). But because of what they are EXPECTING to hear. Perception - visual, and often tactile when installing the cables - will color perception, and lead to a perceived change in the sound.
Did the sonic event change? Usually not (unless the cable is REALLY bad stuff). But the way your brain perceives the sonic event may have changed. And that means your PERCEPTION changed. What you perceive changed.
So, to sum up: amps can sound different, from just a technical standpoint. But more than that, amps can affect our perception of the sound, and that is - in the final analysis of what you experience as sound - just as important as a technical change.
Well, that's about all for now! Merry Christmas, Happy New Year, and see you next time at the Chalk Board!
Dan Wiggins
Adire Audio[/quote']