So you have a sub? If so, you need to set your filters. I set them at around 80-100 hz depending on how high my subs can go, then match the HPF. It takes a lot of work away from the mids that way. It also sounds like the HU is seeing 2 ohms from those JBLs, which means you're not putting the ~40W that you think you are, you're actually pushing closer to 80W. That may be going past the mechanical limits of the driver. That also could be putting your HU at risk since I'm pretty sure it's not 2 ohm stable. It'll do it for a while, and maybe you have enough ventilation behind your dash to push it forever, but your speakers are apparently not dealing with it very well. An easy way to tell is that your new speakers shouldn't be louder than your sick ones, just cleaner at higher volumes. By doubling the power (or halving the resistance) you should get close to +3 dB out of the speakers which should be pretty noticeable, but you can also hook up a multimeter to the terminals and see what she reads. With it on a flat surface and no pressure on the cone it should be somewhere in the neighborhood of 2 ohms if Kai Winters is correct. You did mention it's a component setup, so check at the input to the crossover. If it's reading 2 ohms, then either get speakers with a higher resistance, or baby them and don't go over about 35 on the HU (assuming yours is like my MEX-610BT and it goes to 50) you may want to consider getting a sub so you can push the bass from a driver meant to handle it and get more usable power from your mids.
Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk