What is?

[SHO'NUFF]

No, I just learned pretty young how to find information. And I have a damn good memory. Both skills came in pretty handy when I had to write reports in grade school, term papers in high school, research papers in college.

I guess you never did any work to get your claimed "degree in biology" where you did "extensive" study in anatomy, huh? Was it one of those online deals, like where you get certified as a preacher and can perform marriage ceremonies for only $49.95?

Or did you go to a real school and just deny all of the textbooks and teachings as false, because you are a big rebel who questions all authority and never accepts facts that others have verified?

I guess you never took any classes that stressed critical thinking, logic or philosophy. I wouldn't think an objective person would attempt to pigeon hole someone into a false dilemma.

 

[RobGMN Premium Member]

I guess you never took any classes that stressed critical thinking, logic or philosophy. I wouldn't think an objective person would attempt to pigeon hole someone into a false dilemma.

HE pigeonholes himself.
He presents two mutually exclusive options, then claims one is a choice but the other is not.

A critical thinker would say “If one of two options is not a choice, then the other cannot be a choice. It’s a failure of logic.”

Philosophy has nothing to do with Calling bullshit to declarative statements that someone makes. Sorry.

 

[SHO'NUFF]

HE pigeonholes himself.
He presents two mutually exclusive options, then claims one is a choice but the other is not.

A critical thinker would say “If one of two options is not a choice, then the other cannot be a choice. It’s a failure of logic.”

Philosophy has nothing to do with Calling bullshit to declarative statements that someone makes. Sorry.

Do you not see that you did the same thing?

 

[RobGMN Premium Member]

Do you not see that you did the same thing?

By pointing out his failure of logic?
No.

Can you share what I did?

 

[ThxOne Premium Member]

Typical fail.

Thought so.

 

[RobGMN Premium Member]

Thought so.

Try harder next time.

 

[ThxOne Premium Member]

Try harder next time.

Ditto.

 

[SHO'NUFF]

By pointing out his failure of logic?
No.

Can you share what I did?

I quoted what you did and made it bold.

You did exactly what I said you did, you limited his response options to a false dilemma. A logical fallacy; makes me think the reasoning you use to come to your conclusions isn't sound.

 

[RobGMN Premium Member]

I quoted what you did and made it bold.

You did exactly what I said you did, you limited his response options to a false dilemma. A logical fallacy; makes me think the reasoning you use to come to your conclusions isn't sound.

I honestly do not see a quote in this string of messages where you accused me of forcing Thxone into a false dilemma.

You answered my request for proof by saying you already posted it. Yet, nothing is there.

Can you post again?

 

[Jimi77 Premium Member]

I honestly do not see a quote in this string of messages where you accused me of forcing Thxone into a false dilemma.

You answered my request for proof by saying you already posted it. Yet, nothing is there.

Can you post again?

You did pigeon hole Thx into a false dilemma, but it's a false dilemma of Thx's own creation. You didn't take Thx's posts and arrive to his decision for him, Thx himself clearly took the position that heterosexuality is not a choice but homosexuality is a choice. That's a position which defies logic. Ie if I choose not to be a **** (or any other "perversion"), then I have chosen heterosexuality (or celibacy), but heterosexuality isn't a choice. And of course if I'm deciding against A, then of course I would be comparing A to B (and, C, D, E...) and thus making a decision.

 

[ThxOne Premium Member]

How are people still talking about this?

I know that if you are born male, thanks to good old fashioned schooling, that you have *** with a female to produce offspring. It is THE ONLY natural, biological way to procreate. It is not a choice, it is how you produce smaller humans. This is what *** is for. It is why he produces sperm, she produces eggs. Pleasure is a byproduct.

The ability to go pleasure yourself with same *** people does not make heterosexuality the choice. It means you have made the choice to focus on the byproduct of *** for self gratification and you have chosen to do so with whatever group of people that will allow you to do it readily without persecution.

Being ghey is one of the most selfish acts a human can do. But it is what it is. Now, stfu Rob.

 

[Jimi77 Premium Member]

How are people still talking about this?

I know that if you are born male, thanks to good old fashioned schooling, that you have *** with a female to produce offspring. It is THE ONLY natural, biological way to procreate. It is not a choice, it is how you produce smaller humans. This is what *** is for. It is why he produces sperm, she produces eggs. Pleasure is a byproduct.

The ability to go pleasure yourself with same *** people does not make heterosexuality the choice. It means you have made the choice to focus on the byproduct of *** for self gratification and you have chosen to do so with whatever group of people that will allow you to do it readily without persecution.

Being ghey is one of the most selfish acts a human can do. But it is what it is. Now, stfu Rob.

 

[Jimi77 Premium Member]

Now this is your false dilemma.

I do like this little lie in the article: ***** women have been eligible for female athletic events for the past 12 years – but not a single one has yet qualified for an international-level competition.

***** athletes have competed in international competitions including the Olympics and it's disingenious to pretend they don't have an advantage over biological females. Unfortunately, I don't know if that part about going thru puberty is a good thing. Will cause parents to use puberty blockers or rush the decision to transition their children?

https://www.theweek.co.uk/news/spor...return-to-sanity-or-unleashing-forces-of-hate

 

[RobGMN Premium Member]

How are people still talking about this?

I know that if you are born male, thanks to good old fashioned schooling, that you have *** with a female to produce offspring. It is THE ONLY natural, biological way to procreate. It is not a choice, it is how you produce smaller humans. This is what *** is for. It is why he produces sperm, she produces eggs. Pleasure is a byproduct.

The ability to go pleasure yourself with same *** people does not make heterosexuality the choice. It means you have made the choice to focus on the byproduct of *** for self gratification and you have chosen to do so with whatever group of people that will allow you to do it readily without persecution.

Being ghey is one of the most selfish acts a human can do. But it is what it is. Now, stfu Rob.

Talk about choosing your hill to die on.

You will defend to your death your belief that of only two options, one is not a choice, but the other is.

A complete and obvious failure of logic from the word go, but then you’ll write paragraphs trying to justify the belief.
It’s just plain silly to work so hard to build your argument on a false premise.

Do you have any idea why you do it so often?

 

[Jimi77 Premium Member]

Talk about choosing your hill to die on.

You will defend to your death your belief that of only two options, one is not a choice, but the other is.

A complete and obvious failure of logic from the word go, but then you’ll write paragraphs trying to justify the belief.
It’s just plain silly to work so hard to build your argument on a false premise.

Do you have any idea why you do it so often?

I think the problem is you're hung up an illogical position. Clearly it isn't a logical position, but not everybody works on logic or the word be a much more sensible place.

The whole LGBTQxyz thing is a giant exercise in the illogical. I "identify" as woman, therefore I am?!?!?! Seriously that's crazy talk.