Ok, let me elaborate for you, and other extreme fans.
The newest three for me were a very good story. The acting on the part of all actors was very cheesy. Obie was almost as bad as anakin. Special effects were decent, but i could tell they were trying to scale them to the old ones or maybe that is the difference between now and when they were made. But the story saved it really
Again like i said i have never seen any of them. I am half way... probably a lil more now through the first of the older ones (chronologicallly as the films are concerned, so I have watched the newest 3 and I am on the first of the old ones) and I have said my comments based on that.