"If doing the right thing..."If he brought it back, I think you should leave it be. Otherwise the next time "the call goes out" no one will respond.
Whatever "rep" Wes has will be usless, if people learn that doing the right thing gets them nowhere.
Why? So he can do it later and not return something.If he brought it back, I think you should leave it be. Otherwise the next time "the call goes out" no one will respond.
Whatever "rep" Wes has will be usless, if people learn that doing the right thing gets them nowhere.
You seem to miss my point. I'm fully aware that the right thing to do is not to take something in the first-place. (I HATE thieves!) However once someone does something wrong, the right thing to do from that point forward is to try and make it right."If doing the right thing..."
So as long as I return what ever I steal, its ok?
A thief is a thief and always will be. Doing the "right thing" would have been to NOT take the sub in the first place.
Returning it dose not make up for the fact that he took it in the first place. He got scared from the call that was put out and that is the only
reason it was returned.
If that call was never made, OP would still be out a rather nice sub.
Street justice or legal justice....he needs/deserves to get one or the other. (or both)
So you want the word to go out that all is find and dandy as long as you return what ever you steal.You seem to miss my point. I'm fully aware that the right thing to do is not to take something in the first-place. However once someone does something wrong, the right thing to do from that point forward is to try and make it right.
If returning the item changes nothing, there is absolutely no point in returning the item. Next time it wont matter if "the call goes out" because the call wont mean shit.
"Return the item or else I'll do the exact same thing I would do if you don't return the item." There's a proposition for you.
Do you understand why it's a bad idea to kill POW's you take in combat? If the enemy learns that surrendering is a guaranteed death-sentence, every battle after the word gets out will be a bitter, bloody, fight to the last man. (And cost more of your men's lives in the process.)
This is the same principle here. He surrendered the item. Do you want the word to get out that surrendering is a useless proposition?
Likewise, if "the call had gone out" and the item was not surrendered, I think the various forms of justice you referenced would definitely be in order when the guy was caught.
"Come out with your hands up" won't work if you they expect to get shot when they do.
My recommendation to "leave it be" was based on the OP asking the police to investigate and pursue an otherwise unknown suspect.....after that individual had returned the item.So you want the word to go out that all is find and dandy as long as you return what ever you steal.
"Come out with your hands up" 99% of the time ends up with some form of punishment. Not an "ok, he came out so lets let him go scott free..."
And of course you do not want to kill POW's, because you put the lives of our POW's in danger of the same fate.
(I understand that PERFECTLY sir, I have severed in combat.)
And as was stated by the OP, the ONLY reason he gave it back was due to "peer pressure", in other words he was scared. If that fear would have not been there, the OP would still be out of a sub.
The guy did do good but his deed should not go unpunished in some way.