well I am that older guy...reasonable doubt is definitely, without question #1...saying otherwise is something a 20 year old would say...people don't realize a lot of times, when you listen to an album like Reasonable Doubt, you hear the raw hungriness of an artist, and for a guy like Jay-Z that was gifted as well as hungry at that time, it made for an amazing product...He's not hungry now, he's still talented, but with these types of releases you get the sense that he has a quota to meet. So many albums now, the artist will just gets a few "top" beat makers, a few "top" cameos and boom the album almost sells itself, and this is made even easier with itunes and the online marketplace...The resulting product to me is a lot of track skipping...today's mainstream is not like 1995's mainstream, where you had to work much harder to earn your 5 mics or earn the listening rights of Hip-Hop heads by dropping a hot product...now, partially hot gets you top of the charts...
of course tastes vary from gen to gen, but for an artist that has crossed generations, the argument is relative...