If you have the space for an unusually large box, the new style XXX would perform very well. But imo the Brahma's enclosure requirements are much more realistic for the car environment. And before you say it, RE's box recommendations are way too small for that driver, you'll never reach xmax before reaching the thermal limits of the coil. But again, if you have enough space, and enough power, the new XXX is a potent speaker. It would do great in a home theater environment where space constraints are minimized.
Both designs have their advantages, but for my personal needs Id probably chose the Brahma.