Its obvious who has better stats and that is Tracy, but I like the play of Baron Davis. He is very fearless and seems to be able to bring his team together unlike Tracy. Baron does have an attitude sometimes and gets himself in trouble, but I would still take Baron over T-Mac. With that said, both are very good at their respectful postitions. Kinda unfair comparison.
About Redd, I wish we had him in Cleveland, but he does take way to many shots and not sure how he would get along with LeBron. Would have been interesting to say the least, but IMO more than likely would have been a headache.