So the clay helps dampen some of the sound. Also what's the life span. I'm not planning to change the system for a while. Just trying to think ahead.
Clay vs Constrained Layer Damping (CLD) - what most people refer to as "sound deadening" mat.
Clay:
- no constraining layer (ie foil)
- poorer ability to return to form (ie elasticity)
- more mass per sq ft or sq inch, etc
CLD:
- constraining layer
- superior ability to return to form
- less mass
All depends which tool you need for which job.
The ability to dampen sound depends on the adhesion of the damper to the resonant surface. Not all CLD products are created equal.
If your baffle is not dense enough, then consider denser materials in the build. Lead is the #1 choice here. It has a density five times greater than poured concrete. It's also an idea blocker of sound because it's just so difficult to move.
HDPE is more dense than MDF and has a different RF.
If the baffle build materials are within the passband of your driver (60 hz to 2 khz ??) then you can modify them to either move them above or below the passband.
Fiberglass has a RF of like 4k IIRC. So it can also be used.
Alternating materials and giving the sound more to "work" though will certainly be a benefit.
I added clay to my baffle because it helped make a great gasket between it and the plastic door card.