If a guy is willing to pay you $50 for an hour's worth of time simply to copy some PMs to help his case in proving that he's been scammed, I would do my personal best as a mod to help him resolve that situation. Especially since you're so honest. I remember that thread and I remember how I felt about k_shutte's responses. Sounds like the other guy is out some money and some time and is probably none too happy about the futility of it all.
Just my two cents since you asked.
I'm unaware of your abilities or privileges as a mod, I merely suggested that you do your personal best within your power to offer some help to a person who may need it and is under the impression that you can offer some. If you can't, there probably wasn't much point in making this thread other than to point a finger and laugh.