Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="adam71" data-source="post: 3113260" data-attributes="member: 549079">Absolutely not.&nbsp; I own more than 100 vinyls and a turntable.I don&#039;t really think you&#039;re comparing your vinyl to a &quot;CD recorded right&quot; as I stated earlier.&nbsp; I stick by my word that a CD recorded the right way is better than a vinyl recording.&nbsp; Just for the simple fact that it&#039;s a superior format.&nbsp; No maintenance.&nbsp; No wear and tear after every playback.&nbsp; Best stereo seperation.&nbsp; And MUCH BETTER dynamic range and frequency response.Next time compare your vinyl to a &quot;reference quality&quot; CD.&nbsp; Like maybe something from Sheffield labs or Telarc.I agree totally.&nbsp; It&#039;s all a matter of taste.&nbsp; I let my buddy borrow my DVD audio of the Alan Parsons Project&#039;s &quot;Eye In The Sky&quot;.&nbsp; He listened and said it sounded better than CD but didn&#039;t sound like vinyl.&nbsp; My response was this.&nbsp; &quot;Why is vinyl necessarily RIGHT?? &quot;&nbsp; I agree vinyl sounds different.&nbsp; It has warmer sound than CD does.&nbsp; Some find this pleasing and some don&#039;t.&nbsp; I like the sound of vinyl too but that doesn&#039;t make it the &quot;correct&quot; sound.&nbsp; It&#039;s just different.&nbsp; That is why I have vinyl in my collection.&nbsp; So I have a variety of sound.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="adam71, post: 3113260, member: 549079"] Absolutely not. I own more than 100 vinyls and a turntable. I don't really think you're comparing your vinyl to a "CD recorded right" as I stated earlier. I stick by my word that a CD recorded the right way is better than a vinyl recording. Just for the simple fact that it's a superior format. No maintenance. No wear and tear after every playback. Best stereo seperation. And MUCH BETTER dynamic range and frequency response. Next time compare your vinyl to a "reference quality" CD. Like maybe something from Sheffield labs or Telarc. I agree totally. It's all a matter of taste. I let my buddy borrow my DVD audio of the Alan Parsons Project's "Eye In The Sky". He listened and said it sounded better than CD but didn't sound like vinyl. My response was this. "Why is vinyl necessarily RIGHT?? " I agree vinyl sounds different. It has [I]warmer[/I] sound than CD does. Some find this pleasing and some don't. I like the sound of vinyl too but that doesn't make it the "correct" sound. It's just different. That is why I have vinyl in my collection. So I have a variety of sound. [/QUOTE]

Verification