Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Rudy" data-source="post: 3637623" data-attributes="member: 568035">Seems odd for someone on a car audio forum to be dismissive of technical discussions, but there you go. I was very clear that Peel &amp;amp; Seal doesn&#039;t have a 100% failure rate. It does have a significant failure rate and that rate increases each summer. You may well be one of those who comes back after next summer to report that you should have paid attention - your P&amp;amp;S just melted. I hope not.In any case, your good luck doesn&#039;t disprove the science. Some people smoke a pack pf cigarettes a day and don&#039;t die from a smoking related disease. Doesn&#039;t make smoking a clever thing to do. Just because you have been lucky doesn&#039;t mean that others will and it definitely doesn&#039;t mean that asphalt can be as effective and reliable as butyl. As explained earlier in this thread, butyl products can be more economical that asphalt because they accomplish much more per unit of area. Might want to fight your way through some of the mumbo-jumbo before making unsupportable assertions that may cause problems for other people.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Rudy, post: 3637623, member: 568035"] Seems odd for someone on a car audio forum to be dismissive of technical discussions, but there you go. I was very clear that Peel & Seal doesn't have a 100% failure rate. It does have a significant failure rate and that rate increases each summer. You may well be one of those who comes back after next summer to report that you should have paid attention - your P&S just melted. I hope not. In any case, your good luck doesn't disprove the science. Some people smoke a pack pf cigarettes a day and don't die from a smoking related disease. Doesn't make smoking a clever thing to do. Just because you have been lucky doesn't mean that others will and it definitely doesn't mean that asphalt can be as effective and reliable as butyl. As explained earlier in this thread, butyl products can be more economical that asphalt because they accomplish much more per unit of area. Might want to fight your way through some of the mumbo-jumbo before making unsupportable assertions that may cause problems for other people. [/QUOTE]

Verification