fossil99ca
10+ year member
Member
I don't have tones of experience here. My Maxima have very nice (deep) door speaker holders made from plastic. These are open to the inside of the door. I thought it would be a good idea to enclose with some fiberglass the back of the speaker holder to make a sealed enclosure. I am running Infinity 605cs and found that the woofer was somewhat stifled by the added air resistance. I ended opening up the back of the enclosure with a hole saw to allow them to breath again. I was not worried about water in my doors as they are very dry. I noticed about 5-10% more sound output but quality didn't change much.
My point is, most speakers this size are designed to run free air. I'm not familiar with these foam baffles, maybe they breath. I think most important, you need to seal the front of the speaker from "seeing" the rear of the speaker (prevent air movement from the front of the speaker seeing the back of the speaker). However this is done does not matter. If your doors have a lot of holes, it might be a good idea to use the baffle to accomplish this. If you can use the door as a baffle and it is dry, I dont think they are required. I think this is proven by the others who cut out the bottom of the baffle (as recomended). My 2 cents
My point is, most speakers this size are designed to run free air. I'm not familiar with these foam baffles, maybe they breath. I think most important, you need to seal the front of the speaker from "seeing" the rear of the speaker (prevent air movement from the front of the speaker seeing the back of the speaker). However this is done does not matter. If your doors have a lot of holes, it might be a good idea to use the baffle to accomplish this. If you can use the door as a baffle and it is dry, I dont think they are required. I think this is proven by the others who cut out the bottom of the baffle (as recomended). My 2 cents