Well it depends.
Are you going for SQ, SPL or a mix (SQL)?
Also what amp are you going to be using to power your subs?
The only sub in your list that I have owned is the Shivas and they had awesome SQ and they could get nice and loud!!
I also took the advice of this forum and just bought a eD15A. I'll let you know who it turns out.
Eclipse 8445|Alpine Type X 137r|Diamond D5 300.2/1200.1|ID 10v.3|
Refs: KARLEON, sephiroth619, SiX, Showrides, angrytrucker78, davidfre21, Relax, Slammed
He who laughs last is usually the slowest...