Which sub to buy? - HELP

[whatsinaname]

Here is my set up...
Front - Focal 6.5" (165KF)
Mids - ID OEM's (like the CX64)
Amp - probably 5 channel Focal or Arc

As for subs I have it down to three...
Focal (11") 27v2
ID Q10
JL 10w6

Also I can get a good deal (save a few $$) on a new IDQ 12"

Should I take the ID Q12 or stay with a 10/11" sub. Will the 12 sound perform the same as the 10" (response, tightness, reverb, etc).

IF not the 12" then which 10/11"?

Want to stay sealed with about 1cu ft space.

Opinions/help needed.

Thanks

[ctmike]

personally, i'd take the idq12". if the w6 was a 12" i'd probably lean towards that. however, never heard the focal so i can't comment on that sub.

[GAM3OVR]

that focal is real nice, but $$$$$$.

Id go with a ID Q 10.

Tightness and size of the subwoofer are not as related as you think they are.
There are "tight" 15's out there

[whatsinaname]

Anyone else?

[JUHL]

i agree with projectpechkin... thats what i would prefer out of those

[whatsinaname]

Is there a big sound difference between the ID Q 10" and 12"?

[dftnz7]

I am running the ID OEM mids and CTX tweets upfront, and an IDQ12 in 1.0^3 sealed. It is ******** inducing. Buy the IDQ. Please. For the love of your wang.

[WhoSayWho?]

I would go with a 12" -- either Focal or JL. Well, 11 or 13 with Focal.

[whatsinaname]

I would go with a 12" -- either Focal or JL. Well, 11 or 13 with Focal.

Why not the ID?

Pick one...the Focal or the JL

[WhoSayWho?]

Why not the ID?

Pick one...the Focal or the JL

The IDQ sounds good, but the output just isn't nearly enough in my experience. All thimgs being equal, I would go with the JL.

[whatsinaname]

I am running the ID OEM mids and CTX tweets upfront, and an IDQ12 in 1.0^3 sealed. It is ******** inducing. Buy the IDQ. Please. For the love of your wang.

I wouldn't want to upset my wang

How do you like the OEM's?

[whatsinaname]

The IDQ sounds good, but the output just isn't nearly enough in my experience. All thimgs being equal, I would go with the JL.

The ID's are rated for 500w I think. I don't plan on giving the sub more than 300W total @ 2ohm.

I plan on using the sub just for SQ (I listen to a lot of jazz and old rock).

[whatsinaname]

Picked up the ID Q12V3 D4 on ebay (new in the box). Save about $100.00 from retail.

Also have a set of ID OEM's on the way

[denim]

Dayton HO or Mach5 IXL?

If not, I would lean towards the IDQ or W6 , then the Focal if you can find a good deal on it.

[tuff57]

the w6